Leader DarkAura_17
|
Which would win a fight? WK.1Starting this week, I will post a new topic on the "Will win a fight scenario?" The units are closely matched in price. Also, I will post one each week, and I will evaluate the winner the next week. Vote for your favorite one!!
NOTE: These battles will take place on an open field.
2x T-34/76 VS. 1x Tiger I
The Tiger I with its powerful 88mm cannon can make short work of the T-34/76's. The T-34's however outnumber the Tiger.
|
Leader DarkAura_17
|
Re: Which would win a fight? WK.1 | Leader DarkAura_17 wrote: | Starting this week, I will post a new topic on the "Will win a fight scenario?" The units are closely matched in price. Also, I will post one each week, and I will evaluate the winner the next week. Vote for your favorite one!!
NOTE: These battles will take place on an open field at a medium distance. If you want PM me ahead of time which ones you want to see.
2x T-34/76 VS. 1x Tiger I
The Tiger I with its powerful 88mm cannon can make short work of the T-34/76's. The Tiger has nearly 100mm of frontal armor. The T-34's however outnumber the Tiger. They could easily outmaneuver the Tiger onto its weak rear. |
NEXT WEEK: 1x King Tiger VS. 1 Guards T-34/85 and 1x T-34/76
|
Cpt. John Miller
|
You should add an option for a tie, because this one could go either way, depending on range, terrain and support. I would have voted tie, but I went with the Tiger because of extended range.
|
Leader DarkAura_17
|
| Cpt. John Miller wrote: | | You should add an option for a tie, because this one could go either way, depending on range, terrain and support. I would have voted tie, but I went with the Tiger because of extended range. |
Yes but no. In war there can be no second placers. I agree the Tiger and T-34's could tie or everyone would die, but it is a battle to the finish. First one down loses.
|
Campbjj
|
Range kills.
|
Cpt. John Miller
|
| Leader DarkAura_17 wrote: | | Cpt. John Miller wrote: | | You should add an option for a tie, because this one could go either way, depending on range, terrain and support. I would have voted tie, but I went with the Tiger because of extended range. |
Yes but no. In war there can be no second placers. I agree the Tiger and T-34's could tie or everyone would die, but it is a battle to the finish. First one down loses. |
What I'm trying to say is that half the time the Tiger might win, and the other half the T-34s depending on the above factors and more importantly, the dice rolls. One Tiger can take down 10 T-34s if the Russians roll 1s the whole time right?
|
Leader DarkAura_17
|
OOPPS, I accidentally put this in the Army Builds Section. Moderators can you put this in the General Discussion if you can.
|
Duck Crusader
|
Gotta go Tiger on this one.
|
Lt_Vleclopity
|
On an even playing surface, there will be times the T34s will win but if they were battling right now on even money, I would go Tiger, too big too powerful and with the extended range LOOK OUT!!!!!
|
Ducky
|
I had a Veteran Tiger kill four T-34/76s, and all they did on their way out was damage it (the SU-85 did however succeed in finishing it off eventually, but my Panther killed it and I won)
|
RAEVSKI
|
i normal find that it takes 3 t34 to take a tiger out for sure but it depends on terrain.
|
OberstOz
|
You need more details. An open field? Are we playing on a 50 hex map with no terrain?
Everybody is saying the tiger's extended range clinches it for them and i agree. In this instance the t-34s don't even get a shot off.
Now in a normal game where extended range doesn't count for a whole lot, the t-34s speed give them the edge and 2 shots are better than 1.
|
