| Archive for Axis & Allies ForuMINI Specialised in the World War II Axis & Allies Miniatures and War At Sea Games |
Axis & Allies ForuMINI Forum Index -> Online matches  |
| acs0424 |
Scenario Playtest; Looking For OpponentHey to all,As some of you know I have written 2 scenarios that are posted in AAM scenarios. I am looking for an opponent to playtest 1 of these against. If you are interested post here with which scenario you would like to play and which side you'd like to take. The Scenarios: http://aaminis.myfastforum.org/about10364.html http://aaminis.myfastforum.org/about10371.html Let me know, berger |
||
| carrion |
sure, you choose which one and which side you want. | ||
| acs0424 |
LOL I said you choose! Alright. Lets do Losto Island, I'll take Japs.
Can you do maps? Those specific maps are the backside of NA. Here is the army: Japan SNLF Paras x12 Honor Bound Hero x1 SNLF Captain x3 SNLF Fanatics x1 AHF Infantry x4 Arisaka Rifle x4 Type 97 Antitank rifle x2 Type 92 MG x2 70mm Type 92 x2 Imperial Sniper x1 Type 87 Armored Car x5 Zero x4 Type 95 Ha-Go x1 Type 2 Ka-Mi x1 Type 97 Chi-ha x1 Type 97 Te-ke x1 Alright. |
||
| carrion |
Yeah I know, but you know which ones need more play testing, so let you choose. Will try to have map ready tonight and maybe this afternoon, with all units. Need to look over special rules and such. | ||
| acs0424 |
Yup no problem. If you have any questions just ask! | ||
| carrion |
QUESTIONS: -Recon: Why adjacent and not LOS. -The P-40 needs to roll 5 or 6 before they can enter the battle and once they enter they can spot and attack. Thats about it for now. |
||
| acs0424 |
Hm, these questions are good. I said adjacent because the Japs had good camo and all, seeing them from 500 meters away might be hard.
The P-40 can enter the battle whenever it wants. So it goes in on top of a Arisaka, it rolls a 6, the P40 sees the arisaka attacks it and Japan loses surprise. Now if you dont mind im gonna add something to the P40 rule to make it more realistic. The Japanese can shoot at the P-40 even if the P-40 fails is recon roll, however this would result in the P-40 discovering the Japanese and the Japanese losing Surprise. Then the question becomes is killing 1 plane worth losing surprise? Now if you think LOS would be better for recon then I think it could be changed, but LOS within med. range, not long. Alright my deployment: Armored Cars in W1 V2 W3 V4 W5 SNLF Captain + Arisaka x2 in V6 SNLF Captain + Arisaka x2 in V8 SNLF Captain + AHF Inf in W9 AHF inf x2 + Imp. Sniper in V10 MG x2 + Fanatic in W11 Antitank Rifle x2 + Type 92 Artillery x1 in V12 Type 92 Artillery in W13 Ha-Go in V14 Chi-Ha in W15 Ka-Mi in V16 Te-Ke in W17 init for first turn: Rolls: (2d6)   +2
|
||
| carrion |
We will go with your way first and then go from there.
Will have map with your units ready later today, if all goes well. you have Int first two turns. |
||
| carrion |
your move. |
||
| acs0424 |
3 Paras on C9
3 Paras on C11 3 Paras on D10 3 Paras on C13 Armored car into forest for the 2 foremost cars Rolls: (1d6) 
Rolls: (1d6) 
|
||
| acs0424 |
1 makes it. Move up an armored car from behind to take its place. All infantry move up 1 hex.
The forest BTW is U3 Ha-Go to R14 Te-Ke to T18 Ka-Mi to S15 Chi-Ha to T16 your move commander. |
||
| carrion |
Paras:...you may deploy this unit on the map in any hex that isn't adjacent to an enemy unit. It can't move that phase. | ||
| acs0424 |
Oh snap! O.o Never used em like that. Guess I used em wrong in my self playtest too.
Alright hm... C5 D4 D6 E5 Put 3 paras in each of those hexes. |
||
| carrion |
OK, will change para drop also with your infantry moving up hex, they can only enter jungle hex during assault phase.
SMG defensive fire TeKe from t16 to t18 Rolls: (2d6)
SMG defensive fire KaMi from t16 to s15 Rolls: (2d6)  
|
||
| acs0424 |
Really? Forgot to check my map holder thingy. Alrightg fine with me. Defensive fires missed. I'll get my assault phase up later. | ||
| carrion |
Hero deploys in d10.
your plane. |
||
| carrion |
Correction Priest moves into D10 also. will fix map. | ||
| carrion |
Map fixed with updated move.
your plane. |
||
| acs0424 |
Plane in B10
Do you place planes every other? |
||
| carrion |
No you place all yours I place mine. unless you want to make it like WAS. | ||
| acs0424 |
No that's how I play as well, but i know some people do it every other.
Alright. Plane #2 in L16 Plane #3 in B8 Plane #4 in B12 |
||
| carrion |
your assault. This should be fun. |
||
| carrion |
you can roll my covers, untill you start missing them all. 
|
||
| acs0424 |
Zero Against Red Devil Rolling 9
Rolls: (8d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Zero Against red devil rolling 9 Rolls: (8d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Zero against headquarters Rolls: (8d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Zero against sniper Rolls: (8d6)
70mm against owen rolling 7 Rolls: (7d6)
Sniper against vet SMLE Rolls: (5d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Ha-Go rolling 7 against owen Rolls: (7d6)
Chi-Ha rolling 6 against owen Rolls: (6d6)
Ka-Mi 7 against owen Rolls: (7d6)
AHF x2 to owen in r8 Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
70mm in v12 rollng against vet smle Rolls: (7d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
U7 units to T6 U9 units to T8 V8 units to U7 V10 units to U9 Antitank rifles to jungle in U13 Armored car in U3 to S3 V2 to U1 for armored car Rolls: (1d6)
V4 to U3 for armored car Rolls: (1d6)
SNLF's in E5 shooting at headquarters Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
D4 paras to D10 quad 50 Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
D6 paras to the M1919 mg Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
Rolls: (5d6)
cover Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
Rolls: (1d6)
alright, lets see what happens. |
||
| acs0424 |
Alright.
Casualties: Sniper is destroyed Owen in T16 disrupted Vet SMLE destroyed Quad 50 in D10 disrupted Wow my Paras suck at shooting. The armored car got into U3 Alright, shoot back. |
||
| carrion |
So I'm guessing surprise is over next round.
-Sniper is in a hill hex-[cover=1d6] -Vet SMLE and Owen in R8 have Camo, so they are unaffected. -Car in U3 needs a movement roll to get into T2 to make it to S3. -Quad 50 has defense of 4, so unaffected. My assault coming soon. |
||
| carrion |
Oops SNIPER cover roll-Rolls: (1d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Owen u3 CA vs KaMi-Rolls: (5d6)
Owen s15 CA ChiHa-Rolls: (5d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Vet SMLE vs Sniper-Rolls: (7d6)
M5 n18 vs HaGo-Rolls: (7d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Sniper vs Capt t8-Rolls: (5d6) +1
cover-Rolls: (1d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Toma a17 vs Zero b10-Rolls: (5d6)
Toma c17 vs Zero b12-Rolls: (5d6)
|
||
| acs0424 |
No the car doesnt. It's already in a forest hex. | ||
| carrion |
Quad 1st g3 vs Zero b8-Rolls: (6d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Quad 2nd shot vs Zero b12-Rolls: (6d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Quad 1st g13 vs Zero l16-Rolls: (6d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Quad 2nd g13 vs Zero b10-Rolls: (6d6)
|
||
| carrion |
Yeah but it's not in the other forest hex. Need a roll for each forest hex, not just the first one, unless you can prove otherwise. |
||
| carrion |
3 Garands g11 vs 3 Paras d6
1-Rolls: (8d6)
2-Rolls: (8d6)
3-Rolls: (8d6)
|
||
| carrion |
2 Garands f12 vs 2 Paras e5
1-Rolls: (8d6) ...coverRolls: (1d6) -1
2-Rolls: (8d6) ...coverRolls: (1d6) -1
|
||
| acs0424 |
Can you prove that you need to make a roll to enter each forest hex moving from a forest hex?
Logically the terrain doesn't change so why should I have to make another movement roll? |
||
| carrion |
MG 1st f12 vs unhit para d6-Rolls: (8d6)
MG 2nd f12 vs unhit para e5-[Rolls: (8d6) ...cover-Rolls: (1d6) -1
|
||
| carrion |
It's a different hex..you look for a "you can" and I will look for a "you can't"...sound fair. |
||
| carrion |
Quad d10 vs 2 Paras d4
1-Rolls: (8d6) ...cover-Rolls: (1d6) -1
2-Rolls: (8d6) ...cover-Rolls: (1d6) -1
|
||
| acs0424 |
Sound fair to me. It's late. I'll get back to you tomorrow.
Also, if niether of us can find rules lets each roll a die. the higher roll wins the rule, |
||
| carrion |
Priest vs unhit para d4-Rolls: (10d6)
Hero vs the other unhit para d4-[dice=7d6...cover-Rolls: (1d6) -1
|
||
| carrion |
REROLL-Hero
Rolls: (7d6) ...cover-Rolls: (1d6) -1
|
||
| carrion |
M5A1 o3 vs Arisaka t8-Rolls: (7d6) ...cover-Rolls: (1d6)
|
||
| carrion |
RECAP:
Destroyed: Japan 4 Zeros 1 Para d4 2 Paras d6 HaGo Sniper 1 Arisaka t8 US Sniper Disrupted: Japan KaMi Capt t8 3 Paras e5 2 Paras d4 1 Para d6 US SMG t16 
**Will adjust Cars after we find out for sure** your move. |
||
| carrion |
Advanced Rules p.30:
movement roll: Units attempting to cross a stream or a hedge; Vehicles attempting to enter a forest hex; and Soldiers attempting to enter or leave a bluffs hex through a cliff must succeed on a movement roll to do so... |
||
| acs0424 |
And my arguement against that is it doesn't state where they are coming from. That rule is up for interpretation. | ||
| carrion |
A forest hex is a forest hex, there is no interpretation.
Ask the rules section and see what they say. |
||
| acs0424 |
whatever you win the rule. not like im gonna win anyways. | ||
| carrion |
You just had a bad round of die rolls. You still have your main force coming up from the south, plus this is why you playtest things to see the ins and outs, not to win everytime, that is for the the others playing it after it is complete. | ||
| carrion |
asked in the rules section and this is the response:
http://aaminis.myfastforum.org/sutra221222.php#221222 |
| Axis & Allies ForuMINI Forum Index -> Online matches |
||