NeuralDream
|
Creativity Challenge #6 (Custom Card): Vote for the winnerYou have until Sunday night pacific time.
You take into account whatever criteria matter for you in a custom card.
EvilKobra
VonGwinner
techhawk
swarbs
sharpe
Mighty A
Mad Ghost
Lucky Y
Karpovian
carrion
Aquarius
erratum for this entry by Aquarius: It should say "...make a two dice torpedo attack at up to range 3."
|
afilter
|
Great Job to all, a tough choice.
|
RAEVSKI
|
nice to see an axis flame thrower.
|
USS Virginia BB 13
|
It was a tossup between Aquarius and EK. I went with Aquarius because with this card the Japanese now have a cruiser that's almost worth what it costs.
|
afilter
|
Wow, only 16 votes so far and very evenly spread out. Oh wait that means everyone voted for there own and a few others voted. 
Had to go with the KGV as a personal favorite.
Good Luck to all.
|
WarGamerX
|
Nice Work Everyone!!! 
|
Shank77
|
Nice job on all the cards.
|
NeuralDream
|
Reminder to vote.
|
Campbjj
|
KGV for me.
Wanted to get my card in but must have missed the date.
|
Celt
|
This is a tough contest. Gonna take another day to think on it. They're all good. Some stand out for me though...but still in contention.
Anybody want to buy me vote? JUST KIDDING! 
|
SJG Gamer
|
The Arizona should have the same firepower as the HMS King George V. Its modernized 14/45 guns have the same firepower as British BBs's ten 14/50 guns.
If USS Arizona 's crew had been at battle-stations, and the ship'swater-tight doors & armored hatches closed the 12/7/41 bomb hit forward would have Not have set off the forward magazines. Thus the idea of rolling four 6s causing destruction is not needed & unrealistic...
|
karpovian
|
I disagree.
The whole point of SA's is to add historical relavence to a ship, I could have used the Fatal Flaw SA that the Hood had, but as you said I dont think it was a design issue. Other Pennsylavania class BB's in my cards cost more, but are minus the SA.
Her armament is based off the USS Tennesee, where she is is listed as having a little more secondary guns, this may not make a difference (22 5in as opposed to 14).
This may not be the proper place to debate the stats (Im looking forward to ND's versions in the forouMINI), but I wanted to let you know where the numbers and SA came from
|
Cpt. John Miller
|
I'm detecting a WaS bias in the polls. Makes me glad I didn't design an AAM card for this comp. 
|
Schlachtschiff Bismarck
|
KGV even though the main gunnery stats are a bit high
tenessee max 15 w/ 12 14in
kgv max 16 w/ 10 14in?
|
VonGwinner
|
Yeah really lol
One Day Left!
|
Lt_V
|
They are all excellent, this was very tough to decide, so I narrowed down my favs and did the old eeny meeny ......
I did one card through paint and it came out pretty good but you guys are doing some excellent work 
|
NeuralDream
|
A few more hours left.
|
The_lucky_Y
|
| Cpt. John Miller wrote: | | I'm detecting a WaS bias in the polls. Makes me glad I didn't design an AAM card for this comp. |
better to devide further challenges in WAS /AAM only imho.
|
NeuralDream
|
| The_lucky_Y wrote: | | Cpt. John Miller wrote: | | I'm detecting a WaS bias in the polls. Makes me glad I didn't design an AAM card for this comp. |
better to divide further challenges in WAS /AAM only imho. |
This is not very practical. I've already made that mistake once, when I asked for WAS custom map. Now I'll have to do an AAM custom map competition too to be more fair with the AAM-only fans. But this, in turn, will make the olympics even more unfair for those who don't have great image editing skills. I don't think there should be two competitions on the same skill.
About this specific competition, there are 5 AAM entries and 6 WAS entries, which I think is quite balanced.
|
NeuralDream
|
1. MadGhost 7 pts
-. EvilKobra 7 pts
3. Aquarius 4 pts
4. Carrion 3 pts
5. Sharpe 2 pts
-. VonGwinner 2 pts
|
